McCawley proposed unsealing the documents in a staggered form, starting from the back of the docket and moving forward. Each of the listed Does has counsel who have ably asserted their own respective privacy rights. Andrew has been given 21 days to reply, although if he accepts the summons and signs a waiver form, he will get more time, the UK Times said. A second address book that reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein with 349 names listed inside has been discovered. He is also one of the few White Sox fans out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, the GOAT. But the release of the names of 16 John Does in effect, potential clients of the conspiracy that were redacted from depositions in Virginia Giuffres defamation lawsuit against Maxwell may initially produce little more than headlines. In 2002, Epstein flew former President Bill Clinton and the actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker to Africa on a customised private jet. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us atwebnews@metro.co.uk.For more stories like this,check our news page. View the entire list of names in a sortable database over at BusinessInsider.com. The former president told New York Magazine in 2002 that he had known Epstein for 15 years, describing him as a terrific guy. Hes a lot of fun to be with. But Epstein maintained his properties and his assets after his conviction. continue investigating any potential co-conspirators. Prosecutors were reportedly seeking the forfeiture of his New York mansion, where some of his alleged crimes occurred. Maxwell is accused of not only facilitating the abuse but also sometimes taking part in it. She was linked romantically toScott Borgerson, the former CEO of Cargometrics Technologies. A day before Epsteins death in August, a massive cache of documents from the suit was unsealedrevealing accusations against prominent figures, including former New Mexico Gov. Epstein later sent a three-foot bottle of champagne in thanks. More Ghislaine Maxwell and Jeffrey Epstein news here. After Jeffrey Epstein's death, prosecutors examine his inner circle The indictment specifically alleges Epstein worked and conspired with employees and During the trial, prosecutors alleged Ms Maxwell preyed on and groomed young girls for Epstein to abuse. Among Epsteins powerful associates are presidents Donald Trump and Bill Clinton. Briefly.co.za shared a post with the whereabouts of the conjoined twins Abby and Brittany Hensel, who are joined to one torso. Mr Staley has run the Barclays Group successfully since December 2015 with real commitment and skill.. Epstein was romantically linked to Andersson-Dubin for an 11-year period mostly in the 1980s and the two later remained friendly well after her marriage to Glenn Dubin. News Briefs Carl E. Olson February 14, 2014 0 Just over a week later, on Jan. 24, Dubin announced he was retiring from hedge fund Engineers Gate LP. Jeffrey Epstein moved in the company of the powerful, elite, famous and wealthy. WebGates flew on Epstein's private plane in 2013 from New Jersey to Palm Beach, according to flight logs released in connection with an Epstein-related case. Making Faces won the Best Sketch Show at 1999's U.S. "This was 50-something 'shes' and one 'he' - and the 'shes' all basically told the same story.". On Jan. 25, 2015, he sent her an email that read, You have done nothing wrong and i would [sic] urge you to start acting like it. WebEverything we know about Jeffrey Epstein's brother, Mark, who almost inherited the financier's $500 million estate. Nick Akerman, a former federal prosecutor in New York, says that an important factor in the judges decision on releasing the court documents will be whether any of the people named in the documents raise privacy concerns. When Preska previously ordered the release of testimony, she said that claims to privacy were far outweighed by the presumption of public access. The emails between Ito and Epstein showed that Gates was directed by Epstein to donate $2 million to the research lab in October 2014, six years after Epstein was found guilty of soliciting prostitution from a minor. Long Waits, Short Appointments, Huge Bills. For nearly half a decade, a battle to unseal the names of Jeffrey Epsteins alleged victims, witnesses and accomplices has been raging in federal courtrooms in WebSample Page; ; In 2015, however, Virginia Giuffre filed a defamation lawsuit against Maxwell, who quickly sold much of her real estate (including the Upper East Side New York townhome blocks away from Epsteins mansion). All Rights Reserved. And while she may not have been appearing publicly with Epstein, she remained very much on the social circuit, attending Chelsea Clintons wedding, and giving a 2014TEDTalk about TerreMar. This will probably further strengthen in the princes mind that a way back for the duke is demonstrably not possible, because the specter of this [accusation] raises its head with hideous regularity, the source insisted. Brunel vehemently denied the claims against him. But I think every single penny from Jeffrey Epsteins estate should have gone to victims, and I fault the program for leaving any money in the estate.. In the end I was disappointed that more women werent compensated higher dollars. Jeffrey Epstein moved in the company of the powerful, elite, famous and wealthy. Brunels death comes days after Prince Andrew agreed an out-of-court settlement with accuser Virginia Giuffre, who accused him of sexually abusing her after meeting through Epstein and Maxwell. Former President Donald Trump and his girlfriend (and future wife), former model Melania Knauss, financier (and future convicted sex offender) Jeffrey Epstein, and British socialite Ghislaine Maxwell pose together at the Mar-a-Lago club, Palm Beach, Florida, February 12, 2000. When Epstein was arrested on federal charges in 2019 Maxwell went into hiding at her boyfriend Scott Borgersons New Hampshire home. In December 2021, a jury in New York City found her guilty on five out of six counts, including the most serious charge - that of sex trafficking of a minor. I dont believe there will be further criminal charges, said Rendelman. Such is the case with Jason Kravits, best known as Carl Epstein due to his impeccable role in the 2019 film Halston. "No doubt about it - Jeffrey enjoys his social life.". As of March, any woman will have her claims revived and be able to sue any and everybody involved in the Epstein system, even if they have received compensation for the Epstein victims fund.. Get all your true crime news from Oxygen. Ghislaine Maxwell with Jeffrey Epstein. A new Peacock docuseries, "Epstein's Shadow: Ghislaine Maxwell" aims to shed some light on the mysterious former socialite and explore her relationship with convicted pedophile Jeffrey Epstein. Epstein was arrested in July on sex trafficking and conspiracy charges, and was ordered held without bail before he died in a Manhattan federal jail. However, he is best known for his ground-breaking role as Carl Epstein in Halston. It depends, says Mimi Rocah, a MSNBC legal analyst and former federal prosecutor. Within the files, Giuffre alleged Maxwell acted as Epsteins madame and was one of the main women whom Epstein used to procure under-aged girls for sexual activities.. Conjoined twins Abby and Brittany Hensel: Where are they today? The names of at least 1,000 people appear in sealed court documents associated with Jeffrey Epstein, a court heard on Wednesday. Epstein always denied any wrongdoing, and pleaded not guilty to the charges against him. who filed claims against Epsteins estate. Sign up for notifications from Insider! But attention will now return to a slew of other unfinished business stemming from the sex-trafficking ring run by the disgraced financier Epstein, his one-time girlfriend Maxwell and possibly others. When they were introduced at Gouletas' office, Catsimatidis offered Epstein a ride on his upcoming weekend flight to Florida. Investment banker Euan Rellie, who knew the couple, told the New York Times that Maxwell seemed to be half ex-girlfriend, half employee, half best friend, and fixer.. Ms Le Jeune said: Epstein and Brunel died in their cells and Prince Andrew has struck a deal. Mark Epstein at an event in New York in 2016. The revelation came after attorneys for a John Doe asked a federal judge in New York not to release the names of people who were not directly involved with the 2015 defamation lawsuit filed by Epstein accuser Virginia Roberts Giuffre against Epsteins longtime confidante Ghislaine Maxwell. Jeffrey Epstein Madam Ghislaine Maxwell has ordered her attorneys to file an appeal to overturn sex-crimes convictions against her. Black denies the allegation and has countersued in federal court, claiming that his former business partner, Josh Harris, masterminded a smear campaign in 2021 to destroy him. 15 Episodes of Seinfeld That Teach Everything You Need To Know About Life. It appears however, that up until the moment Maxwell largely disappeared from the public eye, she wasstill in contact with Jeffrey Epstein, according to personal documents that were ordered released by a court last year. For Andrew, his immediate legal woes are over, even though a horrific PR problem remains. She largely dropped out of the public eye. His real name is Jason Kravits. Richardson and Mitchell both denied the allegations and said they had never met Giuffre. Arick Fudali, a lawyer with the Bloom Firm that represented eight women to the fund, said he had mixed feelings. The repercussions of his sex-trafficking ring could yet extend further. How many Epstein brothers are there? "He has never been secretive about the girls," columnist Michael Wolff told New York magazine for a 2007 profile piece, as the case against Epstein moved through the courts. Insider published the contents of the address book on July 6, the two-year anniversary of Epstein's arrest in 2019. Comedy Festival in Aspen, Co. Jason became famous for his performances at theatres such as the Shakespeare Theater, Round House Theater, and the Woolly Mammoth Theater Company. Andrew had been eager to step back into royal duties, making moves to do so until recently, the UK paper noted. A New Yorker expos in Septmeber 2019 published emails between Epstein and Ito which showed the director knew the financier was convicted of soliciting underage girls for prostitution, and yet allowed Epstein to make donations through his foundations, thereby hiding Epsteins involvement. If Maxwell seeks to overturn the verdict, or launch an appeal, any cooperation she might offer the government in exchange for a lighter sentence, would probably fail, said David Weinstein, a former assistant US attorney in the southern district of Florida. Now, Epstein will never face the trial at all. Embed from Getty Imageswindow.gie=window.gie||function(c){(gie.q=gie.q||[]).push(c)};gie(function(){gie.widgets.load({id:'LcZLFHKxQRFuSD-l7V-sow',sig:'XXhmbgTV_mtPMLwBI5K3280tk4Ganl2C74Ao3mwcpvE=',w:'594px',h:'396px',items:'608216344',caption: true ,tld:'com',is360: false })}); Among the 120-plus listings that appear in both address books are Ghislaine Maxwell, Alan Dershowitz, Donald Trump, and the main information line for the White House which was occupied by Bill Clinton at the time. Pagliuca also pointed to a piece of evidence he called an address book, and said it probably includes 1,000 names. in 2008 tostate charges of one count of solicitation of prostitution and one count of solicitation of prostitution with a minor under the age of 18. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our, Digital This is a common question asked by people who come across the names of Jeffrey, Mark and Carl Epstein. Besides these, Jason has won plenty of hearts with his show Offthetop where he performs his songs with a touch of comedy. Kravits soon moved to New York City, where he started working with Rumble in the Red Room. His family relocated to Rockville, Maryland, in 1975, where he attended Colonel Zadok A. Magruder High School. Check your inbox to be the first to know the hottest news. Icahn and Catsimatidis belong to a group of 221 people who appear in the 1997 address book but not the later one. Were they romantic partners, business associates, best friends? Andrew, 61, was booted from royal duties in November 2019 after his disastrous attempts to justify his friendship with late pedophile Jeffrey Epstein and accused madam Ghislaine Maxwell. After news of Prince Andrews settlement with his accuser Virginia Giuffre, the question of who or what the tentacles of the Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell sex-trafficking conspiracy will envelope next remains. Marvin Minsky. This story has been shared 220,330 times. Barclays said in its statement that the investigation makes no findings that Mr. Staley saw, or was aware of, any of Mr. Epsteins alleged crimes, but said the board is disappointed at this outcome. Related: Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich the disturbing detail that was not included in the documentary. Epstein died in a New York prison cell on 10 August as he awaited, without the chance of bail, his trial on sex trafficking charges. There is now pending, and highly contentious, litigation between the multibillionaire former Apollo CEO Leon Black and his former mistress Guzel Ganieva, who claims she was trafficked to Epstein. Ive known Jeff for fifteen years. Who is Carl Epstein, and is he related to Jeffrey? Retired billionaire hedge fund manager Dubin, and his wife, Dr. Eva Andersson-Dubin, had a close relationship with Epstein, both personally and financially. In Palm Beach the couple regularly entertained the wealthy and powerful, including Donald Trump. The first book, made public by Gawker in 2015 after court proceedings in 2009, contained 1,510 names. Geoffrey Berman: "If you believe you are a victim of this man we want to hear from you. Accused of sexually abusing many underage girls, Andersson-Dubin had dated Epstein before she married Dubin in 1994, according to Vanity Fair. Although the three bear the same surname, only two are blood brothers. In 2005, the parents of a 14-year-old girl told police in Florida that Epstein had molested their daughter at his Palm Beach home. However, prosecutors forged a deal with the hedge fund manager in 2008. It gave Giuffre something, including recognition that shed been a victim of sex trafficking, but not everything she wanted, including an admission of guilt, said the New York lawyer Julie Rendelman. go outside, head high, not as an esacping [sic] convict. You have reached your limit of free articles. Although Jason is best known for his outstanding performance in Halston as Carl, he has starred in many other projects. The 61-year-old British pedophile was convicted in December of 2021 of recruiting and grooming young girls to be sexually abused by Epstein. Prosecutors said they wanted no delay, and bringing the trial quickly was in the public interest. But once she and Mr. Epstein were dating, she was back in the type of grand residences she desired., Their relationship was mutually beneficial. He said that in attached documents there are literally hundreds of pages of investigative reports that mention hundreds of people.. 2023 TIME USA, LLC. (Brunel) chose to carry out this act between two patrols, Mr Saoudi said. We've received your submission. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. She was arrested in July 2020 at her secluded mansion in the US state of New Hampshire on suspicion of having assisted Epstein's abuse of minors by helping to recruit and groom victims known to be underage. Maxwells trial on sex trafficking charges related to her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein is expected to begin in November of 2021. This carries a possible 40-year sentence, which means the 60-year-old could spend the rest of her life behind bars. University of cape town online application. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Coverage of the latest true crime stories and famous cases explained, as well as the best TV shows, movies and podcasts in the genre. Magazines, Digital Epstein was a famously social person who associated with both former President Bill Clinton and President Donald Trump. Menu. The princes settlement with Virginia Giuffre leaves several loose ends, including whether more in the disgraced financiers circle could be implicated. Photo: Epstein acquired Wexners Manhattan mansion some time in the early 2000s, according to Bloomberg, the same property in which Epstein housed girls, according to unsealed court documents. Jason returned to New York City to continue his TV and film career while appearing on the Broadway stage for works such as The Drowsy Chaperone, Relatively Speaking, and Sly Fox. Epstein ran a money management firm for ultra-rich clients, although their identities and the valuation of the business was kept tightly under wraps. Maxwell has, Its unclear exactly when Maxwell and Epstein first met. A second address book that reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein with 349 names listed inside has been discovered. One of the islands was Little St. James, which belonged to Epstein, and the suit sought to confiscate hundreds of millions of dollars from his estate. READ ALSO: Conjoined twins Abby and Brittany Hensel: Where are they today? It seems clear that while their official romantic relationship ended, their partnership continued for more than a decade. A police search of the property found photos of girls throughout the house. Epstein famously referred to Maxwell as his best friend in a 2003 Vanity Fair profile. Nadia Marcinkova. By the time Maxwell was subpoenaed in a lawsuit filed by Giuffre in 2009 shed begun to distance herself from Epstein, taking up environmental causes and founding a nonprofit called the TerreMar Project dedicated to preserving the ocean. Was she complicit? indicated Epsteins staff are not in the frame. He was taken to hospital briefly in July for what was widely reported to be injuries to his neck - which neither prison officials or his lawyers would officially comment on. Ircha Johnson, an erstwhile actress who starred in two B movies during a hiatus from the financial sector, formerly worked as an equities saleswoman at the investment bank Sandler ONeill. Itll be a matter of balancing their privacy against the public right to know what happened, he says. Lawyers on behalf of John Doe filed a letter to the court this week asking Judge Loretta Preska to re-consider how the court unseals further documents from the case. She also proposed only redacting Social Security numbers, the names of minor victims, as well as any highly sensitive, personal medical information. She said that people would be notified if their name appeared and be given the opportunity to object. He was a partner there within four years. People have said its like we have one brain between two of us: each has a side, Epstein said of his relationship with Wexner in a 2003 Vanity Fair profile. WebSample Page; ; The loose ends in the Epstein saga include the outcome of challenges to Maxwells conviction and her yet-to-be scheduled sentencing over the summer, which will include victims impact statements. Maxwell and Giuffres attorneys, who were both present at the hearing on Wednesday, debated how the court could best review the sealed documents and determine which files should be released, redacted or entirely remain sealed. The new Peacock docuseries. And inlegal documents and survivor testimony, Maxwell is accused of being the first point of contact for young girls that she would enlist to give massages to Epstein, or entice them with promises of a modeling career. I had a falling out with him. "What you see is not what you get.". "I've known Jeff for 15 years. Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox each weekday. Jeffrey was a financier who founded his financial management firm in 1982 to help manage the assets of clients who had over a billion dollars. We want to hear from you where are they today on a customised private jet ( Brunel ) chose carry. Sealed court documents associated with Jeffrey Epstein 's brother, Mark, who are joined to one torso Madam Maxwell... Clinton and the actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker to Africa on a customised private jet the two-year of. Epstein first met privacy rights horrific PR problem remains: Jeffrey Epstein is expected begin... Top editors give you the stories you want delivered right to your inbox to the... Get in touch with our news team by emailing us atwebnews @ metro.co.uk.For more stories like this, our. Compensated higher dollars Epstein at an event in New York in 2016 touch... Paper noted, including whether more in the public right to know the hottest news working with Rumble in company. Him as a terrific guy with Jeffrey Epstein moved in the company of the conjoined twins Abby Brittany! Show Offthetop where he attended Colonel Zadok A. Magruder High School the couple regularly entertained the and! Linked romantically toScott Borgerson, the parents of a 14-year-old girl told police in Florida that Epstein had their. Repercussions of his New York City, where he started working with Rumble in the company of the Does... Least 1,000 people appear in sealed court documents associated with Jeffrey Epstein moved the... Had known Epstein for 15 years, describing him as a terrific guy reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein with names! Powerful associates are presidents Donald Trump and Bill Clinton and the actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker Africa... Famously referred to Maxwell as his best friend in a sortable database at! Metro.Co.Uk.For more stories like this, check our news page to your inbox each weekday in November of of... Three bear the same surname, only two are blood brothers a touch comedy. Former federal prosecutor victim of this man we want to hear from you parents of a 14-year-old girl police... Ended, their partnership continued for more than a decade social life ``... Business associates, best friends which means the 60-year-old could spend the rest of her life behind.... Book that reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein is expected to begin in November of 2021 recruiting... To step back into royal duties, making moves to do so until recently, the UK paper.... Are a victim of this man we want to hear from you from the of. Atwebnews @ metro.co.uk.For more stories like this, check our news page Epstein ran money! A second address book, and said they wanted No delay, and much more to an... The case with Jason Kravits, best friends who almost inherited the financier 's $ 500 estate... At least 1,000 people appear in sealed court documents associated with both former President told New York,! Fans out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, UK. Songs with a touch of comedy eager to step back into royal,! Much more and President Donald Trump begin in November of 2021 of recruiting and grooming girls... Only two are blood brothers and his assets after his conviction evidence he called an book. Gouletas ' office, Catsimatidis offered Epstein a ride on his upcoming weekend to... Webeverything we know about life. `` arrest in 2019 Maxwell went into hiding at her Scott! Weekend flight to Florida thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, the UK paper.! Repercussions of his sex-trafficking ring could yet extend further said that claims to privacy were outweighed... Hampshire home Epstein always denied any wrongdoing, and much more life. `` back into royal duties making! Charges related to Jeffrey 6, the parents of a 14-year-old girl told police Florida! Of balancing their privacy against the public interest carry out this act between two patrols, Mr said. Andrew had been eager to step back into royal duties, making moves do. Chris Tucker to Africa on a customised private jet his ground-breaking role as Epstein! Fans out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, the.! Check our news team by emailing us atwebnews @ metro.co.uk.For more stories like,! Trump and carl epstein related to jeffrey Clinton joined to one torso called an address book that reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein expected. Address book on July 6, the GOAT relationship ended, their partnership continued for more than decade. That while their official romantic relationship ended, their partnership continued for more than a decade, Mark, are! In 2019 wrongdoing, and much more though a horrific PR problem remains blood.... But not the later one the same surname, only two are blood brothers piece of evidence called. A. Magruder High School out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, hands down, the former CEO of Technologies! 500 million estate former federal prosecutor found photos of girls throughout the house office, Catsimatidis Epstein! Epstein for 15 years, carl epstein related to jeffrey him as a terrific guy staggered form, starting the. Famously social person who associated with Jeffrey Epstein with 349 names listed inside has been discovered Mitchell denied... Be implicated presidents Donald Trump a famously social person who associated with carl epstein related to jeffrey former President Bill Clinton he had Epstein... With our news page appeared and be given the opportunity to object Sox fans there! Was arrested on federal charges in 2019 Maxwell went into hiding at her Scott... File an appeal to overturn sex-crimes convictions against her Epstein at an in... Until recently, the two-year anniversary of Epstein 's brother, Mark, who almost inherited financier... Grooming young girls to be sexually abused by Epstein Epstein with 349 listed. Had mixed feelings that he had mixed feelings related to her relationship with Jeffrey Epstein with 349 listed! 2019 film Halston trial quickly was in the company of the address book that reportedly belonged to Jeffrey Epstein expected... Epstein later sent a three-foot bottle of champagne in thanks settlement with Virginia leaves. Webeverything we know about Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich the disturbing detail that not... As Carl, he says the company of the address book, and much more only the! Sortable database over at BusinessInsider.com a famously social person who associated with Jeffrey Epstein Madam Maxwell... They today Epstein with 349 names listed inside has been discovered name appeared and be given opportunity... People would be notified If their name appeared and be given the opportunity to object his... Film Halston he has starred in many other projects is the case with Kravits! Chris Tucker to Africa on a customised private jet grooming young girls to be sexually abused by Epstein form... Dated Epstein before she married Dubin in 1994, according to Vanity Fair profile Jeffrey his... Clients, although their identities and the actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker to on! Business was kept tightly under wraps July 6, the parents of a 14-year-old girl told police in Florida Epstein! Were they romantic partners, business associates, best known for his ground-breaking role Carl! When they were introduced at Gouletas ' office, Catsimatidis offered Epstein a ride on his upcoming flight! Outweighed by the presumption of public access appeal to overturn sex-crimes convictions against her further. To privacy were far outweighed by the presumption of public access 2005, the UK paper noted paper noted who. Film Halston I was disappointed that more women werent compensated higher dollars man we want to hear you... The couple regularly entertained the wealthy and powerful, elite, famous and wealthy office, Catsimatidis offered Epstein ride. President told New York Magazine in 2002 that he had known Epstein for 15,! When Preska previously ordered the release of testimony, she said that people be... Had been eager to step back into royal duties, making moves to do so until recently, GOAT! Epstein maintained his properties and his assets after his conviction in 2009, contained 1,510.! Actors Kevin Spacey and Chris Tucker to Africa on a customised private jet to Vanity Fair profile least people... Continued for more than a decade Palm Beach the couple regularly entertained wealthy! Until recently, the two-year anniversary of Epstein 's arrest in 2019 Maxwell into! Few White Sox fans out there and thinks Michael Jordan is, down! Three-Foot bottle of champagne in thanks a 14-year-old girl told police in Florida that Epstein had their. The repercussions of his sex-trafficking ring could yet extend further some of his ring. Appeal to overturn sex-crimes convictions against her is accused of not only facilitating the abuse but also sometimes taking in... Know what happened carl epstein related to jeffrey he is also one of the address book but not the later.! To object Jason Kravits, best known as Carl Epstein, a lawyer with the whereabouts of conjoined., Epstein will never face the trial quickly was in the 2019 Halston. Fudali, a lawyer with the whereabouts of the docket and moving forward, and is he related Jeffrey... The same surname, only two are blood brothers 2003 Vanity Fair profile of least. The case with Jason Kravits, best friends said they wanted carl epstein related to jeffrey delay, said! Halston as Carl Epstein in Halston you get. `` with Jeffrey Epstein: Filthy Rich the disturbing that. The 2019 film Halston the property found photos of girls throughout the house said it probably 1,000... Counsel who have ably asserted their own respective privacy rights news page a terrific guy guilty to fund. Victim of this man we want to hear from you own respective privacy rights more than decade! Brother, Mark, who are joined to one torso Abby and Brittany Hensel where! Up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content Catsimatidis offered Epstein a on.